I am currently taking an intercultural class and we had a controversial discussing whether you can sell American values. In your opinion, can you sell American values? Is that ethical? Here's my report in this issue.
A person can try
to “sell American values” but at the end, they will not be successful. However,
cultures can imitate American values if they seem interested. As an example,
when the movie Titanic came out, Leo-mania fever started. Leonardo DiCaprio
became one of the hottest and most talked about actors in the entertainment
industry. A friend of ours went to Japan during the launch of Titanic and she
said, the majority of the guys were coloring their hair and dressing like
DiCaprio because they wanted to imitate the “American fashion” and they wanted
to get all the girls. In this case, it seemed like Japan wanted to “borrow
those trends.” Selling values, pressuring values also reminds me of the movie
Bruno. A controversial movie about a German homosexual played by Sasha Boren Cohen that comes to America
wanting to be part of the American fashion and entertainment industry. In one
scene of the movie, he is with a pastor in Alabama learning the values and ways
to be heterosexual. Of course, the scene it’s hilarious because of the way the
actor is portraying everything but it makes you think, can you sell other
values? Why pressure a person, in this case, culture to be more
“American”?
I believe it’s
ethically wrong to “sell American values” to other cultures. It’s wrong to sell
any values from another country to another society, period. I decided to listen
to the whole podcast of “Shouting Across the Divide,” in the American Life segment. In the first act, shocked
me when Cloe is in class and the teacher tells her if you don’t believe in
Jesus you are going to hell. Number one that teacher should’ve been fired on
the spot but number two, how egotistical and ethnocentric of her to try to
change her beliefs. “It is clear that religion and culture are inextricably
entwined…. Religion and civilization seem to have gone hand in hand in the evolution
of human society to an extent that one could conclude that they are coequal and
coterminous, ” (Samovar, pg. 105). We need to be more respectful and open
minded to other cultures. Again, you can try to sell other values but you will
not be successful.
Persuading
cultures to be more American it’s a form of ethnocentrism. “People have great
pride in their cultures; they must, because culture is their source of
identity; they have difficulty understanding why others do not behave as they
do, and assume that others would like to be them if they could,” (Samovar, pg.181). Cultures have been around for centuries, why try to change an entire
population thought process?
Ginolly, I really liked your post. Every culture has something to contribute to everyone and Americans need to be more open to others. Thank you so much for sharing this with us. :)
ReplyDelete